Peer Review Process
Engagement uses double-blind peer review. The identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the process, and manuscripts are prepared for review without author names, affiliations or acknowledgements.
Initial screening
Every submission is first read by an editor for fit with the focus and scope, completeness of the manuscript, and whether the paper reports an engagement with identifiable community partners. Similarity is checked with Turnitin, and a manuscript with a similarity index of 20 percent or more is returned or declined. Manuscripts that fall outside the scope, that report activity without a research question and method, or that cannot identify the community involved are declined at this stage without external review.
Reviewers
A manuscript that passes screening is sent to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in its subject area. Reviewers are selected by the handling editor from the journal's reviewer pool and from specialists identified through the manuscript's references and field. A reviewer must have no institutional affiliation with any author and no recent joint publication with them.
Reviewers are appointed by the editor. Authors do not nominate reviewers, and a suggestion made in a cover letter creates no obligation: the editor may invite that person only after verifying that no conflict of interest exists, and remains free to disregard the suggestion entirely.
Independence and decision
Each reviewer submits an independent report with a recommendation. The handling editor reads every report in full and decides. No reviewer's opinion carries automatic priority over another's, and where two reports conflict the editor may invite a third reviewer or ask one reviewer to comment on the substance of the other report without revealing identities.
The decision is one of four: accept as submitted; minor revision; major revision, with re-review where necessary; or reject. Revised manuscripts are returned to the reviewers who raised the substantive points wherever possible.
Timeline
Reviewers are asked to return their report within three to four weeks. Authors are given four weeks for a minor revision and six weeks for a major revision. A manuscript normally passes through one or two rounds of review before a decision.
What reviewers are asked to assess
- Fit with the focus and scope, including whether the engagement described falls within one of the journal's subject clusters.
- Contribution: whether the manuscript advances knowledge or practice beyond a description of activities.
- Theoretical grounding: whether the findings are connected to a body of literature and to a conceptual framework, and whether the discussion explains what the results mean for existing understanding.
- Method and evidence: whether the approach to the community work is described well enough to be assessed and repeated, and whether outcomes are supported by data rather than assertion.
- Community role: whether the part played by community partners in designing, carrying out and judging the work is described.
- Implications: whether the manuscript states what follows for practitioners and for policy, and whether it says what remains after the programme ends.
- Ethics: consent, treatment of community data, conflicts of interest, and disclosure of any use of generative AI.
- Clarity and conformity to the author guidelines, including reference style and length.
Confidentiality and conflicts
Manuscripts are confidential. Reviewers must not share, cite or use a manuscript before publication, must not upload it to an external AI service, and must decline the invitation when a conflict of interest exists. Reviewers must not ask authors to cite the reviewer's own work unless the citation is genuinely necessary for the argument.
Appeals
An author who believes a decision was based on a factual error or a breach of process may write to the Editor-in-Chief with the reasons. An appeal is handled by an editor who was not involved in the original decision. The outcome is communicated in writing, and the decision of the appeal is final.